This study was done in conjunction with a series of studies by the Matsuda group that involved the use of high doses of infused vitamin C in severely burned subjects. They had been testing high dose vitamin C as an anti-oxidant in an attempt to diminish the delayed injury that always occurred in severely burned patients. Their initial studies involved rats, guinea pigs and eventually anesthetized dogs to show the efficacy of this technique. There was some resistance in the medical community to using these rather high doses of vitamin C, especially in patients with such a disturbed fluid and salt balance as those with severe or extensive burns.
This study was done to show that high dose vitamin C was not harmful in normal human subjects with the implication being that it may also be safe in burned subjects. Interestingly, this therapy has, in the years since performing this study, become a fairly widely used modality for extensively burned subjects and has proven to be very effective in stabilizing the otherwise precariously unbalanced hemodynamic condition of these patients.
The full paper and a link to the PDF are shown below.
Safety of Continuously Infused High dose Vitamin C
The Safety of Continuous Intravenous Infusion Of
High‑dose Vitamin C in Healthy Humans
by
Takayoshi Matsuda,
M.D., Hideki Yuasa, M.D., Walid Khabaz, M.D.,
Candice Richardson,
Pharm D., Marella Hanumadass, M.D.,
and Robert J. Walter,
Ph.D.
Burn Center and
Department of Surgery, Cook
County Hospital;
Department of
Surgery, University
of Illinois;
Hektoen Institute for
Medical Research, Chicago, IL
Presented at the
Twenty‑sixth Annual Meeting of the American
Burn Association, Orlando, Florida,
April 20‑23, 1994.
Address all correspondence to:
Robert
J. Walter, Ph D.
Division of Surgical Research
Department of Surgery
Cook County
Hospital
627 South Wood Street
Chicago, IL 60612
Tel: (312)-633-7237 (office)
Fax: (312)-633-8347
ABSTRACT
Background: It
has been shown that continuous intravenous infusion of vitamin C in high doses
(14 mg/kg/hr) decreases postburn capillary permeability and reduces the
resuscitation fluid volume requirements by 75% in burned animals.
Methods: In the
present study, the effects of an 8 hr intravenous infusion of high‑dose vitamin
C (0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 gm/hr) were evaluated in 4 healthy adult volunteers.
Results:
Plasma vitamin C levels ranged from 4 to 16 μg/ml at baseline, and
increased to 41-90 μg/ml during the infusion of 0.5 g/hr vitamin C, to 92-152
μg/ml during the 1 g/hr infusion, and to 162-290 μg/ml during the 2 g/ hr
infusion. Plasma vitamin C values
decreased rapidly after termination of the infusion and returned to baseline by
16 hours postinfusion. None of the
subjects developed any subjective symptoms.
Vital signs, EKG monitoring, urinalysis, and hematology and chemistry
blood tests before, during, and after the vitamin C infusion were all within
normal limits.
Conclusions:
Continuous intravenous infusion of up to 2 g/hr of vitamin C for 8 hrs
appeared to have no adverse effects on healthy adult humans.
Key Words: VITAMIN C,
SAFETY, ANTIOXIDANT, HIGH‑DOSE
INTRODUCTION
Burn injuries cause increased
capillary permeability which results in extensive fluid and protein leakage
from the intravascular space. For
extensively burned patients, a massive volume of fluid is required for
resuscitation during the first 24 hours postburn in order to prevent
hypovolemic shock. Friedl and associates
have demonstrated that increased postburn capillary permeability is due to
capillary endothelial damage caused by free radicals generated by the increased
activity of xanthine oxidase 1.
We have previously demonstrated in animal studies that continuous
intravenous infusion of a natural antioxidant, vitamin C, in high doses (14
mg/kg/hr) minimizes the burn tissue lipid peroxidation 2 and reduces
fluid and protein leakage from the intravascular space to the interstitial
space 3. We have also shown
that, for guinea pigs with 70% body surface area (BSA) burns, the resuscitation
fluid volume requirements can be reduced by 75% with adjuvant administration of
vitamin C 4. It has also been
reported that the administration of vitamin C must be continued for at least 8
hours in order to maintain adequate hemodynamic stability when the burned
animals are resuscitated with a reduced fluid volume 5.
Before this high‑dose vitamin C
therapy can be advanced to a clinical trial in burned patients, the possible toxicity
or adverse side effects of such therapy must be determined. The present study was undertaken to evaluate
the safety of short‑term intravenous infusion of high‑dose vitamin C in healthy
human volunteers.
SUBJECTS AND
METHODS
Study subjects. Four (4) healthy male volunteers, ages 28 to
34 years with body weights ranging from 68 to 90 kg, participated in the
study. The experimental protocol was
approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Cook County
Hospital and each subject
signed an informed consent. There was no
financial payment to the volunteers for their participation in the study. One week prior to the initiation of the
study, a complete history was obtained, a physical examination performed, and
baseline blood samples drawn. The
history, the physical examination, and all the blood test values were confirmed
to be within normal limits before the initiation of the study. None of the subjects had a history of kidney
disease, and none were taking routine vitamin C supplements.
Preparation of Vitamin C
Solution. An injectable vitamin C
solution, Cenolate (500 mg/ml; Abbott Laboratories Hospital Products Division, Abbott Park, IL),
was diluted with sterile water at a ratio of 1 to 17.44 (vol/vol). The concentration of vitamin C and sodium in
this diluted sodium ascorbate solution was 27.11 mg/ml and 154 mEq/L,
respectively.
Dosing Schedule. Three different doses of vitamin C (i.e., 8
hour infusion of 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 g/hr) were studied in each of the subjects
with one week intervals between each infusion.
In the first week, a loading dose of 0.5 g vitamin C was infused over 20
minutes, followed by a continuous infusion of 0.5 g/hr of vitamin C (0.26
ml/kg/hr) for 8 hours. In the second and
third weeks, 1.0 g/hr and 2.0 g/hr doses of vitamin C were studied,
respectively, using an identical scheme.
Conduct of the study. The study was performed on the Intensive Care
Unit of the Burn Center at Cook
County Hospital. On the morning of the study day, the subject
was assigned to a bed with ambulation privileges ad libitum. The subject remained in the Burn Center for
approximately 24 hours and then returned to the Burn Center as required for
follow‑up data collection. A regular
hospital diet was provided and water was given ad libitum throughout the study
period.
A catheter was inserted into a
forearm vein for blood drawing and then kept open with a heparin lock for
subsequent blood samplings at predetermined intervals during and after the
infusion of vitamin C. After obtaining a
blood sample for the baseline measurement, a venous catheter was inserted into
the opposite forearm and the vitamin C infusion was initiated.
Monitoring
and Data Collection. Vital signs
were measured every hour during the infusion, and every 4 hours thereafter
until 12 hours postinfusion. The subject
was placed on a continuous EKG monitor.
Fluid intake and urine output during the study day were recorded. Urinalysis (specific gravity, pH, sugar,
acetone, protein, blood, and microscopic examination) was performed prior to
the vitamin C infusion, during the 24‑hour study period (i.e., 8 hours infusion
and 16 hours postinfusion), and at 24 hours and 7 days postinfusion. Hematological tests (CBC and coagulation
profile) and blood chemistries (sodium, potassium, chloride, bicarbonate,
calcium, glucose, total protein, albumin, globulin, phosphorus, cholesterol,
urea nitrogen, creatinine, alkaline phosphatase, SGOT, SGPT, GGT, and LDH) were
performed at baseline, at the end of the vitamin C administration, and at 1 and
7 days postinfusion. Tests for urine and
blood as described above were determined in the hospital's central clinical
laboratories.
Blood samples for venous blood
gases were drawn at baseline, and at 1, 2, 4 and 8 hours during the vitamin C
infusion. These results were determined
in the Neonatology Stat Laboratory of Cook County Hospital. Plasma vitamin C levels were drawn at
baseline, and at 1, 2, 4, and 8 hours during the vitamin C infusion, and
analyzed in the Burn Center research laboratory using HPLC 6.
RESULTS
Each of the four subjects completed
the three‑week study for the evaluation of the three different doses of vitamin
C. None of the subjects developed any
subjective symptoms that may be related to drug reaction such as headache, dizziness,
nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, or diarrhea.
Vital signs monitored during the study periods remained essentially
within normal limits. There were no abnormalities detected in the EKG
monitoring. All the laboratory
measurements before, during, and after the vitamin C administration in each of
the subjects were within normal limits.
Follow‑up examinations and laboratory tests of all the subjects both one
week and one month after the 2 g/hr infusion revealed no abnormalities.
The plasma vitamin C levels of one
of the subjects before, during, and after the infusion of the three different
doses of vitamin C are shown in Figure 1.
The plasma vitamin C levels of all four subjects at 2 g/hr dose are
illustrated in Figure 2. Plasma vitamin
C levels of all the subjects ranged from 4-16 μg/ml prior to the vitamin C
infusion. Levels increased to 41-90
μg/ml during the infusion of 0.5 g/hr vitamin C, to 92-152 μg/ml during the 1
g/hr infusion, and to 162-290 μg/ml during the 2 g/hr infusion. The plasma vitamin C values of all the
subjects decreased rapidly after termination of the infusion, and returned to
baseline by 16 hours postinfusion.
DISCUSSION
Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) is a
six-carbon, water‑soluble vitamin which is structurally related to glucose and
other hexoses 7. Its
physiological functions are numerous.
Severe or prolonged deficiency leads to the clinical condition known as
scurvy. The recommended daily dietary
allowance of vitamin C for the healthy adult is 60 mg/day 8, which
will prevent signs of scurvy for at least 4 weeks. Vitamin C is also a well-known
naturally-occurring antioxidant 9‑11. We have previously shown that continuous
intravenous infusion of vitamin C in high doses (14 mg/kg/hr) decreases burn
tissue lipid peroxidation 2, minimizes postburn capillary
permeability 3, and reduces the resuscitation fluid volume
requirements in burned animals by 75% 4. When vitamin C is administered via
intravenous infusion, it is impossible to elevate the concentration of vitamin
C selectively in the burned area only, instead the concentration of vitamin C
in the total extracellular fluid must be elevated to the level required by the
burned tissue. This resulting plasma
concentration of vitamin C is dependent upon the dose of vitamin C administered. The minimum dose of vitamin C that was
necessary to achieve the desired therapeutic effects in our animal experiments
was 14 mg/kg/hr 4. This
dosage, equivalent to 1,000 mg/hr for a 70 kg adult, is very large as compared
to the physiological maintenance dose (60 mg/day) and represents a
pharmacological dose.
Pauling 12 has advocated
the ingestion of large doses of vitamin C as an antioxidant for health
maintenance. His recommended daily dose
is 0.25 to 5 grams for a healthy adult based upon the extrapolation of the rate
of vitamin C synthesis observed in animals 12. In addition, he recommends an even greater
dosage, 5 to 20 g/day, for the treatment of illnesses such as the common cold 13. The efficacy and safety of so‑called
"megadose" vitamin C ingestion for the common cold, however, is
controversial.
Rivers, one of the organizers of
the "Third New York Academy of Sciences Conference on Vitamin C" held
in 1986, concluded 14 that the use of large quantities of ascorbic
acid did not result in the production of calcium‑oxalate stones, increased uric
acid excretion, impaired vitamin B12 status, iron overload, systemic
conditioning, or increased mutagenic activity in healthy individuals. The only contraindication regarding the ingestion
of large quantities of vitamin C mentioned in that paper 14 relates
to patients with renal impairment and patients on chronic hemodialysis. Furthermore, any reported criticism of
"megadose" vitamin C ingestion has been directed toward chronic or
long‑term usage of high-dose vitamin C.
To our knowledge, the safety of short‑term (e.g., 8 to 24 hours)
intravenous infusion of high‑dose, neutral pH, vitamin C has not been evaluated
elsewhere.
In the present study, none of the
subjects developed any overt symptoms nor abnormal laboratory values associated
with the high‑dose vitamin C infusion.
Although the number of subjects studied was small, it appears that
continuous intravenous infusion of up to 2 grams per hour of vitamin C for 8
hours is not detrimental to healthy adult humans.
Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) has a low
molecular weight (176 g/mol), and passes freely through the glomerular
filtration barriers. Reabsorption of
ascorbate from glomerular filtrate in the renal tubules is an active, saturable
process 14. It has been shown
that the reabsorption mechanism is saturated at plasma levels of 8 to 9 μg/ml 15,16. Plasma ascorbate in excess of that required
to maintain plasma levels at approximately 10 μg/ml is, therefore, efficiently
eliminated by the kidney. The rapid
decrease in the plasma ascorbate level after the termination of vitamin C
infusion in the present study supports this contention. The continuous high plasma ascorbate levels
depicted during the infusion of vitamin C in the present study suggests that
intake has exceeded the elimination capability of the kidneys resulting in
elevation of plasma ascorbate levels.
REFERENCES
1. Freidl HP, Till
GO, Trentz O: Roles of histamine,
complement and xanthine oxidase in thermal injury of skin. Amer J Pathol
135:203, 1989.
2. Matsuda T, Tanaka
H, Yuasa H: The effects of high‑dose
vitamin C therapy on postburn lipid peroxidation. J Burn Care Rehabil 14:624,
1993.
3. Matsuda T, Tanaka
H, Hanumadass M: Effects of high‑dose
vitamin C administration on postburn microvascular fluid and protein flux. J
Burn Care Rehabil 13:560, 1992.
4. Matsuda T, Tanaka
H, Williams S: Reduced fluid volume
requirement for resuscitation of third degree burns using high dose vitamin C.
J Burn Care Rehabil 12:525, 1991.
5. Tanaka H,
Broaderick P, Shimazaki S: How long do
we need to give antioxidant therapy during resuscitation when its
administration is delayed for two hours? J Burn Care Rehabil 13:567, 1992.
6. Dennison DB,
Brawley TG, Hunter GL: Rapid high‑performance
liquid chromatographic determination of ascorbic acid and combined ascorbic
acid‑dehydroascorbic acid in beverages. J Agr Food Chem 29:927, 1981.
7. Gilman A, Goodman
L, Rall T., eds. The phamacological basis of therapeutics. New York: MacMillan Publishing Co. 1985;
1567‑1568.
8. Food and Nutrition
Board, National Research Council. Recommended dietary allowances. 1989; 10th
edition:p 118 Washington, DC. National Academy
of Sciences.
9. Nishikimi M: Oxidation of ascorbic acid with superoxide
anion generated by the xanthine‑xanthine oxidase system. Biochem Biophys Res
Comm 63:463, 1975.
10. Bielski BHJ,
Richter HW, Chan PC: Some properties of
the ascorbate free radical. Ann NY Acad Sci 258:231, 1975.
11. Bodannes RS, Chan
PC: Ascorbic acid as a scavenger of
singlet oxygen. FEBS Letters 105:195, 1979.
12. Pauling L.
Vitamin C, the common cold, and the flu. San
Francisco: W.H.Freeman and Company, 1976; 145‑146.
13. Pauling L.
Vitamin C, the common cold, and the flu. San
Francisco: W.H.Freeman and Company, 1976; 148
14. Rivers JM: Safety of high‑level vitamin C ingestion. Ann
NY Acad Sci 498:445, 1987.
15. Hagler L, Herman
RH: Oxalate metabolism. I.
Amer J Clin Nutr 26:758, 1973.
16. Hagler L, Herman
RH: Oxalate metabolism. II.
Amer J Clin Nutr 26:882, 1973.
FIGURES
Figure 1. The plasma
vitamin C levels of one of the subjects before, during, and after the infusion
of three different doses of vitamin C (i.e., 0.5, 1.0, or 2.0 g/hr). The plasma vitamin C levels increased
rapidly, remained elevated throughout the 8 hour infusion period, and decreased
rapidly upon termination of the infusion.
Figure 2. Plasma
vitamin C levels of four subjects infused at a dosage of 2 g/hr. The plasma vitamin C levels increased to 162
to 290 μg/ml during the infusion period, but decreased rapidly upon termination
of the infusion. Vitamin C levels for
each subject are shown as individual data points and the mean of these four
data points at each time is shown as a line.
FYI. The content on this blog is copyright protected by the author. Feel free to read, copy, and disseminate the studies described here, but please indicate the origin of the work by citing this blog URL as an electronic web citation when it is appropriate to recognize and attribute the work of others.